Banff or Canmore? Where I'd Stay for Three Different Trips
Three nights without a car, a week with the family or a hiking trip into Kananaskis? A Canmore local weighs up the buses, beds and evenings that make each town a good base.
I live in Canmore, and if you had three nights, no car and Lake Louise at the top of your list, I'd tell you to book Banff. Give me a week, a kitchen and a couple of days to walk in Kananaskis, and I'd start looking much closer to home.
The two towns share a river and a stretch of highway. What separates them for a visitor is where you'll have breakfast, where tomorrow's bus leaves from and what you'd like to do after dinner. Here's how I'd choose for three quite different holidays.
A short Banff trip without a car

For two or three nights, I'd look for a room within walking distance of central Banff Avenue. You can go down to the Bow River before breakfast, have a look at Cascade Mountain from the bridge and still be back in time for coffee. In the evening, everyone can order what they like with dinner. Nobody has drawn the short straw and agreed to drive.
It's also a handy place to start the bigger days. Roam Route 1 takes you to the Banff Gondola on Sulphur Mountain, and the 8X runs from Banff to the Lake Louise lakeshore. On a summer day in town, you could walk the riverbank or join a guided big canoe tour and see it from the water. Our Banff town guide has the riverside walks, picnic spots and places to eat.

If Moraine Lake is your priority, choose your transport as well as your hotel. For most visitors, getting there in summer means a shuttle or tour. Some trips leave from Banff. The regular Parks Canada shuttle leaves from the Lake Louise Park and Ride, so a room in Banff still leaves you a journey to the departure point.
I'd happily do this trip from Canmore for the right room. Roam Route 3 runs daily between the two downtowns, and the ride is about 25 minutes. The extra time to allow is the walk to the stop and, on a Lake Louise day, the connection in Banff. One connection on holiday is easy enough. Making it before every outing is a good reason to stay in Banff. Our Roam Transit guide covers the routes and tickets.
A family week with a kitchen
For a week with children or two couples travelling together, I'd start in Canmore. A separate bedroom gives the early riser somewhere to make coffee while everyone else sleeps. A kitchen earns its keep on the first early hiking morning, when four people can have breakfast without first agreeing where to go.
Stoneridge Mountain Resort is a useful example of what to look for. Its suites have a full kitchen, a living room and their own washer and dryer. That last detail can matter more than the mountain view about halfway through a family holiday. For travellers who like walking out to dinner, I'd also look around downtown Canmore and Spring Creek. The path along Policeman's Creek connects Spring Creek with Main Street.

Banff has an option for the same family. The condos at Hidden Ridge Resort have full kitchens, and guests get passes for Banff's local Roam routes. The resort is up on Tunnel Mountain, so a meal downtown usually starts with a bus ride or a drive. I'd pick Hidden Ridge if most of the week's outings start in Banff and the family wants room to spread out.
For a fair price comparison, put a Canmore suite beside the Banff accommodation you'd actually book. If the alternative is two hotel rooms, use the total for both. Include parking, any cleaning fee and the breakfasts you'd realistically cook. If everyone likes going out for breakfast, a full kitchen has just become a fairly expensive place to keep the milk.
Transport is one cost you can put a number on. At the current Roam fares, two adults taking Route 3 to Banff and back pay $24 between them on single tickets. Children aged 12 and under ride free, as does everyone on Canmore's local routes. Count that $24 on the days you'd actually go to Banff. A day around Canmore costs you nothing in inter-town fares.
A hiking trip split between Banff and Kananaskis
I'd choose the walks first. If Johnston Canyon, Lake Louise and a drive up the Icefields Parkway fill most of the itinerary, Banff gives you a head start going west. Canmore makes more sense when Grassi Lakes, the Canmore Nordic Centre or the trails in Kananaskis are part of the holiday in their own right.
From Canmore you can spend a day on the trails, another visiting Banff and a third beside the Bow without repeating the same drive three mornings running. A guided hike around Grassi Lakes and Grotto Canyon is one way to spend a day on the Canmore side. If the legs have other ideas, the Bow River Loop crosses the old Engine Bridge on a mostly flat walk of about 2 km. The bridge is a reminder of Canmore's coal-mining past, and the views start well before you've done anything to earn them.

The park boundary matters here. Banff town is inside Banff National Park. Canmore is outside it. Alberta's Kananaskis Conservation Pass applies when you park a vehicle at designated provincial park and public land sites, including the Nordic Centre. It isn't needed to stay in Canmore or drive straight through. Our guide to the two passes explains which one applies to each outing.
With a car and a week in the valley, I'd usually unpack once. A second hotel makes more sense if the trip is moving on towards Lake Louise or Jasper. Changing rooms just to move between Banff and Canmore uses up a perfectly good morning for a fairly small change of scenery.
When the rooms are much the same price
Picture coming back from a long day out. In Banff you might leave the car keys on the dresser, walk down Banff Avenue and let whichever restaurant looks inviting settle the dinner question. In Canmore you might pick up something for supper, then take the boardwalk home as the light goes off the peaks. Both are good evenings. Most people know which one they'd like more often.
My tie-breaker is the day I most want to get right. If it's an early Lake Louise bus, I'd take the Banff room. If it's a long lunch on Canmore's Main Street after a morning at Grassi Lakes, I'd stay in Canmore. You can always go and see what the neighbours are up to tomorrow.
Frequently asked questions
Can I stay in Canmore and visit Banff without a car?
Yes. Roam Route 3 links the two downtowns every day. A room within walking distance of a Route 3 stop is the simplest choice. For Lake Louise, allow for a second bus from Banff.
Does a Banff hotel's free bus pass include Lake Louise?
A pass for Banff local routes covers trips within the local network, such as the ride to the gondola. Lake Louise is a separate regional service. The 8X is reservable, which is helpful if the lakeshore is the main reason for your trip.
Where should I stay if I want to walk to dinner?
In Banff, look at central Banff Avenue and the streets around Bear Street. In Canmore, Main Street and Spring Creek put restaurants within walking distance. A hotel's street address tells you more about the walk home than the town name on the booking.
Is Canmore cheaper for a family?
It can be, particularly if one suite replaces two rooms and you'll use the kitchen. Compare the whole stay on the same dates, including fees and transport. A small nightly saving matters much less on a two-night visit than it does over a week.
